top of page

Home
Shop
Events / Calendar
Pickup Partners
Reviews
Contact
FAQ
Articles

Home

Made to Order

Made to Order

Special orders are made-to-order and will take a few days to produce

Special orders are made-to-order and will take a few days to produce…

All Products
Bagels
Butter
Butter (Grass Fed)
Cream Cheese
Create Your Own
Customer Favorites
Flavors of the Month
In Stock Now
Made to Order
Non-Dairy
Partner Products
Savory
Spicy
Sweet

Filter by

Butter

Butter (Grass Fed)

Cream Cheese

Create Your Own

Customer Favorites

Flavors of the Month

In Stock Now

Non-Dairy

Savory

Spicy

Sweet

FRESH BAKED!

Bagels- (6)- Assorted
Price$12.00
FRESH BAKED!

Bagels- 6 Pack
Price$12.00
Made to Order

Blueberry
PriceFrom $5.50
Featured Feb 2024

Bruschetta
PriceFrom $5.50
Featured October 2024

Candied Pecan
PriceFrom $6.00
Featured May 2025

Caribbean Dream
PriceFrom $6.00
Made to Order

Carrot Cake
PriceFrom $5.50
Featured November 2025

Chai Spice Coffee
PriceFrom $5.50
Featured Jul 2025

Cheese Ball: Garlic Herb
PriceFrom $6.00
Featured November 2025

Churro
PriceFrom $6.00
Create Your Own!

Custom Butter (1/2 pound)
Price$10.00
Create Your Own!

Custom Cream Cheese (1/2 pound)
Price$10.00
Returning Jan 2026

French Onion Soup
PriceFrom $5.50
Featured February 2025

Garlic Bread
PriceFrom $5.50
Featured March 2025

Green Goddess
PriceFrom $6.00
Featured Aug 2025

Honey Peach Pecan
PriceFrom $6.00

Now Schmear This!
is proud to be associated with:

2024 Best of Georgia Banner

Flavors of the Month

Customer Favorites

Let's Get Social!

All products are proudly produced according to FDA/GDA food & safety standards in a commercial kitchen in Marietta, GA.

© 2023-2025, Now Schmear This!. LLC

bottom of page