top of page

Home
Shop
Events / Calendar
Pickup Partners
Reviews
Contact
FAQ
Articles

Home

All Products

All Products

Browse our full inventory. Please let us know if you have any questions.

Browse our full inventory. Please let us know if you have any questions.…

All Products
Bagels
Butter
Butter (Grass Fed)
Cream Cheese
Create Your Own
Customer Favorites
Flavors of the Month
In Stock Now
Made to Order
Non-Dairy
Partner Products
Savory
Spicy
Sweet

Filter by

Butter

Butter (Grass Fed)

Cream Cheese

Create Your Own

Customer Favorites

Flavors of the Month

In Stock Now

Non-Dairy

Savory

Spicy

Sweet

Featured November 2025

Churro
PriceFrom $6.00
Featured June 2024

Coffee
PriceFrom $5.50
Featured December 2025

Cranberry Orange
PriceFrom $6.00
Featured December 2025

Cranberry Orange Jalapeno
PriceFrom $6.00
Create Your Own!

Custom Butter (1/2 pound)
Price$10.00
Create Your Own!

Custom Cream Cheese (1/2 pound)
Price$10.00
Create Your Own!

Custom Grass-Fed Butter
Price$12.00
Non Dairy Option

Custom Non-Dairy Butter
Price$12.00
Crowd Favorite

Everything Bagel
PriceFrom $5.00
Returning Jan 2026

French Onion Soup
PriceFrom $5.50
Featured February 2025

Garlic Bread
PriceFrom $5.50
Featured March 2025

Green Goddess
PriceFrom $6.00
Crowd Favorite

Honey Cinnamon
PriceFrom $5.50
Best Seller!

Honey Garlic Jalapeno
PriceFrom $5.50
Featured Aug 2025

Honey Peach Pecan
PriceFrom $6.00
Honey Walnut
PriceFrom $6.00

Now Schmear This!
is proud to be associated with:

2024 Best of Georgia Banner

Flavors of the Month

Customer Favorites

Let's Get Social!

All products are proudly produced according to FDA/GDA food & safety standards in a commercial kitchen in Marietta, GA.

© 2023-2025, Now Schmear This!. LLC

bottom of page